The Lie Tree

The Lie Tree

Book - 2016
Average Rating:
18
2
1
Rate this:
On an island off the south coast of Victorian England, fourteen-year-old Faith investigates the mysterious death of her father, who was involved in a scandal, and discovers a tree that feeds upon lies and gives those who eat its fruit visions of truth.
On an island off the south coast of Victorian England, Faith investigates the mysterious death of her father, who was involved in a scandal. She discovers a tree that bears fruit only when she whispers a lie to it-- and the fruit, in turn, delivers a hidden truth. Does the tree hold the key to her father's murder? Or will it lead the murderer to Faith herself?
Publisher: New York :, Amulet Books,, 2016
ISBN: 9781419718953
1419718959
Characteristics: 377 pages ; 22 cm

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

m
Marilyn34
Nov 01, 2017

This novel shows that you can't let anyone suppress you from what you can do.

Check out my review of "The Lie Tree" on my blog at:
http://axarr.blogspot.com/2017/10/review-wednesday-lie-tree-by-frances.html

DBRL_ANNEG Oct 13, 2017

A fantastic YA novel that will also appeal to adults. The protagonist, Faith, is smart and witty. She is not afraid to get her hands dirty and loves to explore. She can read multiple languages and has a curiosity that is only satisfied through learning new things. Faith lives during the Victorian era, though, and as a girl at this time, she is often held back. But that doesn't stop her from trying to learn as much as she can on her own, leading to quite an independent streak on her part.

Her father, a naturalist who was renowned for his knowledge of the prehistoric world, has brought her family to a remote island so that he can study recently discovered skeletal remains. Faith knows that something else is going on--there are rumblings about her cracks in her father's scientific reputation. So when he mysteriously dies (a presumed suicide), Faith sees evidence to the contrary and sets out to find the truth.

This story has an element of fantasy--it turns out her father has made a miraculous discovery in a tree that can reveal the truth, after it is fed a lie. The tree is an important aspect of the story, but this reader (who does not delve into much fantasy) was thrilled to see how much the story remained grounded in reality. In many ways this book is more of a Gothic, Victorian mystery than a fantasy. The tree has its role, but it didn't overwhelm the story.

I was sorry to see the story end. I actually kind of hope the author finds a way to revisit Faith in the future. She was a delight to spend time with and, if anything, has inspired me to look at more of Frances Hardinge's books.

j
jazpur
Sep 04, 2017

Frances Hardinge has done a brilliant job. A classic murder mystery involved with archaelogical, botanical and scientific studies and the thefts of research material is pursued to its denouement through the endeavours of Faith, a fourteen-year old girl, not prepared to accept the expectations of her place as a young woman in Victorian society ,regardless of her intelligence.Nothing is as it seems.The fantastical gothic elements add to the atmosphere. The book gives a good indication of the darker side of Victorian culture.. This edition has beautiful illustrations throughout by Chris Riddell.

a
admaggies
Aug 08, 2017

Couldn't put it down! Interesting mystery. A realistic look at how girls and women were treated and what was expected of them in Victorian times.

s
SJM7323
Jul 19, 2017

A nice little mystery! I enjoyed it.

b
brangwinn
Apr 23, 2017

Great fantasy with a young female protagonist is set in Victorian England when fossils are being discovered. Faith chafes at the life she is expected to lead—that of playing second fiddle to males. Her father and mother seem to look at her as a babysitter for her younger brother, and yet her mind is sharp. She wants to be a scientist. When her father, a minister who is looked at as an expert in fossils, is sent to a remote island because some of his findings are hoaxes, Faith discovers lots more to the story including a tree that grows stronger when told lies. How she survives others looking for this same tree and in the process, finds out the best lies allow for those hearing the lie to embellish the facts themselves, makes for gripping reading.

kirstd31 Mar 16, 2017

The concept of the story was interesting. But about halfway through I was bored.

v
veruk
Mar 11, 2017

Overall this was a pretty good book. It was well written, with some exceptionally beautiful passages, a creative idea, natural dialogue, and complex characters. The only problem I had with it, though, was that it was adamantly pro-macroevolution. I would have preferred it if it was not, but even so, I do admit that it is a well-written book and would still recommend it, with a grain of salt.

abruzzo79 Feb 22, 2017

Exciting historical novel featuring the male natural scientists collecting "monstrosities and oddity" and the girl who wants to manipulate them and discover their secrets.

JCLChrisK Dec 24, 2016

Hardinge has crafted a wonderfully complex tale with a wonderfully complex heroine. A rationalist mystery with just enough supernatural to give it an even creepier edge. Told with beautiful, eloquent language and delightfully quotable insights.

View All Comments

Notices

Add Notices

mvkramer May 28, 2016

Frightening or Intense Scenes: There's a scene in which Faith's father rejects her dreams of being a scholar that is just crushing.

mvkramer May 28, 2016

Violence: Murder and attempted murder. One incident of family violence. A non-graphic scene of a "ratting" fight between 14 rats and a dog.

Quotes

Add a Quote

v
veruk
Mar 11, 2017

“All the while the air softly hummed with murmured lies.

There were kind lies. You still look beautiful. I love you. I forgive you.

There were frightened lies. Someone else just have taken it Of course I am Anglican. I never saw that baby before.

There were predatory lies. Buy this tonic if you want your child to recover. I will look after you. Your secret is safe with me.

Half-lies, and the tense little silences where a truth should have been. Lies like knives, lies like poultices. The tiger’s stripe, and the fawn’s dusky dapple. And everywhere, everywhere, the lies that people told themselves. Dreams like cut flowers, with no nourishing root. Will-o’-the-wisp lights to make them less alone in the dark. Hollow resolutions and empty excuses.” -- pg. 347

Age

Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at MenloPark

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top